The Fundamental Need for Impartial Justice

Matt Wells, Africa Division, Human Rights Watch

President Alassane Ouattara’s government in Côte d’Ivoire has taken a series of measures to bolster the economy and good governance but has largely ignored one of the country’s main catalysts of political violence: the culture of impunity for those in power. The coming months will show whether the government will fulfill promises of impartial justice and ease the tensions that fuelled last year’s post-election violence, or continue down its current path of victor’s justice, further aggravating the situation. 

Inline_wells1
Figure 1

Former President Laurent Gbagbo’s refusal to step down when Ouattara was proclaimed the winner of the November 2010 presidential run-off triggered six months of violence in which more than 3,000 people were killed. More than 150 women and girls were raped. Based on six field missions during the crisis, we documented the evolution of systematic human rights violations and identified thirteen high-level civilian and military leaders implicated in grave crimes [1] (Figure 1). Gbagbo’s elite security forces and allied militias committed most of the serious violations during the first months of the crisis, and the Gbagbo camp’s longstanding manipulation of ethnicity led to hate speech that incited atrocities. But by the conflict’s end in May 2011, armed forces on both sides had committed war crimes and likely crimes against humanity. Civilians were targeted systematically on political, ethnic, and religious grounds, with widespread killings and rapes in Abidjan and in the country’s western region [2, 3].

During his visit to western Côte d’Ivoire in April 2012, President Ouattara recognized the horrific abuses that marked the crisis and reiterated promises of impartial justice [4, 5]. Civilian and military prosecutors have charged more than 120 people from the Gbagbo camp with post-election crimes, including murder [6, 7]. But no pro-Ouattara forces have been charged with crimes committed during the post-election crisis (Figure 2), and several commanders that Human Rights Watch and others have implicated in overseeing extrajudicial executions and torture have been promoted to high-level positions in the new military [8, 9, 10, 11].

Inline_wells2
Figure 2

On November 29, 2011, the Ivoirian government surrendered Gbagbo to the International Criminal Court to face charges on crimes against humanity. For many victims, the transfer was a significant step toward ensuring justice [12]. However, by initiating proceedings only against Gbagbo—albeit while continuing investigations into crimes by both sides—the ICC reinforced the impression that prosecutions are only advancing against those who lost the post-election conflict. 

As a result, victims from the losing side feel voiceless at home and abroad. A number of moderate Gbagbo supporters whom I interviewed referred to the proceedings as farcical and hypocritical. Most have no objection to Ouattara’s presidency and Gbagbo’s arrest—his refusal to relinquish power destroyed their livelihoods too—but they demand accountability for pro-Ouattara forces as well.

The absence of impartial justice threatens to drive these moderates toward militant, pro-Gbagbo hard-liners, who remain as committed today to inciting communal divisions as during the post-election crisis. While they now lack political and military power, they pose a threat to long-term stability. The unfortunate decision by political parties in Gbagbo’s former coalition to boycott parliamentary elections will increase many Ivoirians’ sense of marginalization which, together with the perception that only the losing side will pay for its crimes, may provoke future violence if recent history is any guide.

Over the past decade, two developments worked in tandem to undermine Côte d’Ivoire’s status as a pillar of economic and political stability in West Africa: The country’s once functional judiciary progressively succumbed to corruption and political influence, and Ivoirians increasingly resorted to violence to settle grievances over land and political power.

Political violence marked the aftermath of the 2000 presidential and legislative elections [13]. During the 2002-2003 armed conflict and the years of “no war, no peace” that followed, war crimes and likely crimes against humanity were committed predominantly by the same armed forces that fought again in 2011 [14, 15, 16, 17]. No one has been held accountable for any of these crimes. A sense of impunity developed for those with political power or guns, and burgeoning militia and self-defense groups often replaced the judiciary with vigilantism.

Returning to the rule of law is fundamental if Côte d’Ivoire is to break away from the country’s recent, bloody history. But, so long as prosecutors and courts appear to administer victor’s justice, deep political and social cleavages will remain and widen. While the Ouattara government and the ICC are right to prosecute those in the Gbagbo camp who committed serious crimes, there should be justice for victims on both sides.

Figures

Figure 1. Cover of Human Rights Watch 2011 report on atrocities in Côte d’Ivoire. Photo: Human Rights Watch [1].

Figure 2. “A young man hides his face after recounting the story of his injuries from post-election violence, Bangolo Hospital, western Côte d’Ivoire. He was shot by advancing pro-Ouattara forces and left for dead until a passing soldier heard him groan. Out of bullets, the soldier began hacking at him with a machete.” Photo: © 2011 Peter diCampo/VII Mentor Program [11].

References

[1] Wells, Matt and Corinne Dufka. 2011. "They Killed Them Like It Was Nothing": The Need for Justice for Côte d’Ivoire’s Post-Election Crimes. New York: Human Rights Watch (accessed May 28, 2012).

[2] Human Rights Watch (HRW). 2011a. Côte d’Ivoire: Post-Election Crimes. HRW Multimedia, October 6 (accessed May 28, 2012).

[3] DiCampo, Peter, Almudena Toral, Jean-Marc Jacobs et al. n.d. Eyewiteness to Post-Election Massacres in Ivory Coast. Time Video, n.d. (accessed May 28, 2012).

[4] West African Democracy Radio. 2012. Ouattara Vows to Bring Perpetrators of Atrocities to Justice. West African Democracy Radio, April 24 (accessed May 28, 2012).

[5] Agence France Presse. 2012. “Tous les meurtriers seront punis,” assure le président ivoirien à Duékoué. Abidjan.Net, April 23 (accessed May 28, 2012).

[6] Konan, André Silver. 2011. Côte d’Ivoire : 128 militaires et civils pro-Gbagbo inculpés pour 22 chefs d’accusation. Jeune Afrique, August 22, (accessed May 28, 2012).

[7] HRW. 2012. Côte d’Ivoire: Inquiry’s Shortcuts Raise Red Flags. HRW News, February 23 (accessed May 28, 2012).

[8] Look, Anne. 2012. Rights Group Condemns Violent Crime Impunity in Ivory Coast. Voice of America News, March 4 (accessed May 28, 2012).

[9] Wells, Matt. 2012. One Year On, Duékoué Massacre Belies Ouattara Government’s Promises of Impartial Justice. HRW News, March 29 (accessed May 28, 2012).

[10] Gomez, Juan. 2012. Côte d’Ivoire : bilan d’une tournée dans l’Ouest. Radio France Internationale, April 25 (accessed May 28, 2012).

[11] HRW. 2011b. Côte d’Ivoire: Military Promotions Mock Abuse Victims. HRW News, August 5 (accessed May 28, 2012).

[12] ------. 2011c. Côte d’Ivoire: Gbagbo’s ICC Transfer Advances Justice. HRW News, November 29 (accessed May 28, 2012).

[13] ------. 2001. The New Racism: The Political Manipulation of Ethnicity in Côte d’Ivoire. HRW Publications, August 28 (accessed May 28, 2012).

[14] ------. 2003. Trapped between Two Wars: Violence against Civilians in Western Côte d’Ivoire. HRW Publications, August 6 (accessed May 28, 2012).

[15] ------. 2004. Human Rights Violations in Abidjan during an Opposition Demonstration—March 2004. HRW Publications, October 14 (accessed May 28, 2012).

[16] ------. 2006. “Because They Have the Guns . . . I’m Left with Nothing”: The Price of Continuing Impunity in Côte d’Ivoire. HRW Publications, May 26 (accessed May 28, 2012).

[17] -------. 2007. “My Heart Is Cut”: Sexual Violence by Rebels and Pro-Government Forces in Côte d’Ivoire. HRW Publications, August 3 (accessed May 28, 2012).