On and Off the Record: Ethnographic Witnessing and Accompaniment in Immigration Court

"Witnessing Effacement" by Zubaida Quassi.

This collection brings together ethnographers engaged in court-watching, accompaniment in and beyond detained settings, expert witnessing, and collaborative documentation projects with attorneys, students, and community partners. These contributions show what sustained presence makes legible but statistics and transcripts often elide, filling in the gap that lies between what appears on the record—procedural language, legal categories, judicial decisions—and what unfolds off the record: confusion, waiting, coercion, dread, and the slow violence embedded in the bewildering churn of new legal guidelines. Unlike the physical border, immigration court does not simply block or channel movement at entry; it remakes the boundary through legal classification, evidentiary judgment, and precedent. In doing so, courts produce records and decisions that extend beyond any individual migrant, shaping how future claims will be heard, what forms of suffering become legible, and whose presence can be authorized or refused.

Posts in This Series

Introduction: On and Off the Record

Introduction: On and Off the Record

The violence of the U.S. immigration regime has come into sharp focus for broad publics in recent months—from courthouse arrests of immigrants seeking relief “t... More

I Hate Going to Immigration Court

I Hate Going to Immigration Court

I hate going to immigration court. I drag myself out of bed and half hope something will happen on the turnpike to prevent me from making it to Newark today. In... More

Deported Elsewhere: When the U.S. Tries to Send Asylum Seekers to a Third Country

Deported Elsewhere: When the U.S. Tries to Send Asylum Seekers to a Third Country

DHS [Department of Homeland Security] attorney: “I am putting you on notice that the ACA [Asylum Cooperation Agreements] for Honduras and Ecuador apply.”Immigra... More

When Asylum Becomes Risk: Notes from Court and Community in the Second Trump Era

When Asylum Becomes Risk: Notes from Court and Community in the Second Trump Era

On a snowy morning in Ohio, a man sits alone before an immigration judge for his master calendar hearing. Without legal representation, he listens as the lawyer... More

Documenting the Upside-Down: The Colorado Court Transparency Project

Documenting the Upside-Down: The Colorado Court Transparency Project

My former student and now project manager, Ella, and I waited for a guard to take us to the courtrooms at the Aurora, Colorado immigration detention center, own... More

The Governance of Fear in U.S. Immigration Courts

The Governance of Fear in U.S. Immigration Courts

Credible. Reasonable. Subjective. Objective. Well-founded. Five words to describe America’s love story with measuring and legally codifying immigrants’ fears. S... More

The Spectacle at Federal Plaza: Student Ethnographers in NYC Immigration Courts

The Spectacle at Federal Plaza: Student Ethnographers in NYC Immigration Courts

“Por miedo,” the asylum-seeking respondent admitted over video when the immigration judge demanded to know why she had not shown up to court in person. “Because... More

The Trap of Compassion: Accompaniment and Discretionary Immigration Enforcement

The Trap of Compassion: Accompaniment and Discretionary Immigration Enforcement

Last spring, as I walked out of the federal courthouse in El Paso after a particularly difficult week accompanying people to their immigration hearings, I ran i... More

Expert Witnessing as Accompaniment

Expert Witnessing as Accompaniment

I wrote this poem that I title, “sometimes,” in January 2020 to help me process my own emotions about writing expert witness declarations in gender violence asy... More

Troubled Times and Shifting Positionalities: Accompaniment in EOIR Courts in Times of State Violence

Troubled Times and Shifting Positionalities: Accompaniment in EOIR Courts in Times of State Violence

On a spring afternoon in March 2026, Oregon’s blue skies wet with the smell of recent rain, I accompanied Hector (not his real name) to his master calendar hear... More

Deportation Is Not the End: Endurance and the Malleability of Accompaniment

Deportation Is Not the End: Endurance and the Malleability of Accompaniment

It has been seven years since I first walked into Adelanto Detention Facility to meet Soli. I was volunteering with an accompaniment team supporting people in d... More

Accompaniment In and Around Detained Immigration Court

Accompaniment In and Around Detained Immigration Court

On a sweltering August afternoon in Aurora, Colorado, César and I sat across from each other on uncomfortable stools in the GEO detention center1 visiting room,... More

When the Law (and Immigration Judges) Stopped Listening

When the Law (and Immigration Judges) Stopped Listening

Each year I bring students to county jails across Minnesota to conduct intake interviews with people detained by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). Beca... More

The Challenge of Trump’s Totalitarian Lawfulness

The Challenge of Trump’s Totalitarian Lawfulness

Malick, a pseudonym, is facing an immigration judge who is over 1,000 miles away and is presiding via WebEx video conference. Malick is being detained in GEO Gr... More